Get ready for a journey back in time, to an era when promises of eternal beauty were sold in small jars. But what happens when reality becomes distorted and illusion becomes the star product? In this episode, we unearth a campaign that reminds us that sometimes, images deceive more than words.
False promises
In 2009, Olay, the renowned skincare brand, launched an advertising campaign to promote its "Definity Eye Illuminator" eye cream. The campaign featured former model Twiggy, then 60 years old, sporting radiant, wrinkle-free skin. The message was clear: "Defy age. Reverse the look of wrinkles and fine lines in just 4 weeks."
Twiggy's image became the centerpiece of the campaign, appearing in magazines, billboards, and television commercials. The model, known for her natural beauty and iconic 60s look, seemed to have defied the passage of time thanks to the power of Olay's cream.
The campaign generated a great initial stir, attracting the attention of consumers and generating an increase in product sales. However, the illusion did not last long. Soon, the UK's Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) received complaints from consumers questioning the veracity of Twiggy's image.
After an investigation, the ASA concluded that the image had been digitally retouched with Photoshop to remove the model's wrinkles and fine lines. The campaign was banned for misleading advertising and Olay was forced to withdraw the ads.
Olay's campaign generated great controversy and criticism from consumers and the media. The brand was accused of promoting unrealistic beauty standards and misleading consumers with false promises.
The campaign also raised a debate about the use of Photoshop in advertising and the ethics of digitally altering people's appearance. Many argued that this practice promotes a distorted image of beauty and can have a negative impact on people's self-esteem, especially women's.
The question for the AI
What do you think of an advertising campaign for an anti-wrinkle cream that shows a 60-year-old model with perfect skin thanks to the use of Photoshop, under the slogan "Defy age. Reverse the look of wrinkles and fine lines in just 4 weeks"?
The AI's response: The campaign, as it is presented, poses several risks:
Unrealistic expectations: The excessive use of Photoshop creates unattainable expectations about the product's results, which can generate frustration and distrust in consumers.
Authenticity: The digitally retouched image can be perceived as inauthentic and misleading, which goes against the transparency that consumers increasingly value.
Inclusion and diversity: The campaign focuses on an unrealistic and exclusive beauty ideal, ignoring the diversity of ages and appearances.
Alternative proposal: Instead of focusing on the elimination of wrinkles, the campaign could focus on:
Real beauty: Show the 60-year-old model with her wrinkles and fine lines, celebrating her natural beauty and experience.
Health and well-being: Highlight the benefits of the eye cream in terms of hydration, luminosity, and skin care, instead of promising miraculous results.
Empowerment: The message could focus on feeling good about oneself at any age, instead of fighting against aging.
Alternative Slogan: "Care for your skin, celebrate your age. Our eye cream helps you look and feel radiant at every stage of your life."
This alternative campaign would promote a more positive and realistic image of aging, encouraging acceptance and self-love instead of the pursuit of unattainable perfection. In addition, by avoiding the excessive use of Photoshop, the brand would demonstrate a commitment to authenticity and transparency, values that are increasingly important to consumers.
A Predictive Revenue Marketing Proposal
Predictive Revenue Marketing has become a powerful tool for companies seeking to optimize their strategies and maximize their results. In Olay's case, a campaign based on this approach could help achieve similar goals to the original campaign, but in a more ethical and transparent way.
Objective: Increase sales of the "Definity Eye Illuminator" cream and improve brand perception among consumers, focusing on the product's real effectiveness and avoiding misleading promises.
Tools used: Olay could collect data from various sources, such as purchase history, social media interactions, surveys, and product reviews. Using predictive analysis algorithms, Olay could identify patterns and trends in the data to predict which customers are most likely to purchase the "Definity Eye Illuminator" cream. Based on the results of the predictive analysis, Olay would segment its customers into groups with different levels of interest in the product. With this information, personalized ads and messages could be created for each customer segment. These messages would focus on the real benefits of the product and how it can help improve the appearance of each customer's skin, avoiding exaggerated promises or digital retouching. These ads would be shown to customers through different channels, such as social media, email, and online advertising.
Measuring Success:
Sales Increase: The increase in sales of the "Definity Eye Illuminator" cream would be analyzed after the implementation of the campaign.
Improved Brand Perception: Surveys and sentiment analysis would be conducted on social media to assess whether brand perception has improved.
Return on Investment (ROI): The ROI of the campaign would be calculated to determine its profitability.
Important Note: It is essential that Olay consider the ethical concerns about data use, privacy, and potential biases in algorithms. The company must be transparent about how it collects and uses customer data and ensure that algorithms do not discriminate against any group of people.
Yorumlar